The Axeman of New Orleans: Jazz, Murder, and Mystery

The Axeman of New Orleans was a shadowy figure who cast a dark pall over the city from May 1918 to October 1919. Operating in a city still reeling from the effects of World War I and the Spanish flu pandemic, the Axeman added to the atmosphere of uncertainty and fear. His brutal attacks, primarily targeting Italian immigrants and their families, left a trail of fear and bewilderment. What made his reign of terror even more bizarre was his purported love for jazz music, as declared in a chilling letter to the press. Despite extensive investigations, the identity of the Axeman has never been definitively determined, making him a subject of fascination and speculation for over a century.

Not credited, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Crimes: A Series of Gruesome Attacks

The Axeman's known victims include:

• Joseph Maggio and his wife Catherine, attacked on May 22, 1918. Both had their throats slit and were bludgeoned with an axe. Joseph died shortly after being discovered, while Catherine succumbed to her injuries later.
• Louis Besumer and his mistress Harriet Lowe, attacked on June 27, 1918. Both were struck with an axe but survived, though Lowe died later from complications.
• Anna Schneider, a pregnant woman attacked on August 5, 1918. She was badly wounded but survived.
• Joseph Romano, attacked on August 10, 1918. He was an elderly man who died two days after the attack.
• Charles and Rosie Cortimiglia, and their daughter Mary, attacked on March 10, 1919. Mary was killed, while her parents survived.
• Mike Pepitone, attacked on October 27, 1919. He was killed in his bed.

The Axeman's method was chillingly consistent: he would gain entry by chiseling a panel out of the back door, then attack the occupants with an axe or a straight razor, often using the victims' own tools. Notably, the attacks were not motivated by robbery, as nothing was taken from the homes, adding to the enigma of his motives.

The Letter: A Chilling Ultimatum

Amidst the fear and confusion, the Axeman made his presence known in a most unusual way. On March 13, 1919, a letter purportedly from the Axeman was published in newspapers. In it, he declared that he would strike again on March 19 but would spare any home where a jazz band was playing. The letter read in part:

'I am very fond of jazz music, and I swear by all the devils in the nether regions that every person shall be spared in whose home a jazz band is in full swing at the time I have just mentioned.'

That night, New Orleans was alive with jazz music, and no murders occurred. This event has become a legendary part of the Axeman's story, blending the city's musical heritage with its darkest moments.

Suspects: The Elusive Killer

Despite the letter and the public's compliance, the attacks continued, prompting a frantic search for the killer. One of the most cited suspects is Joseph Monfre, a man with a criminal background who was shot to death in Los Angeles in 1920 by the widow of Mike Pepitone, the Axeman's final known victim. However, research has failed to find concrete evidence linking Monfre to the crimes, and some historians doubt his involvement altogether.

Other theories abound: some suggest the killer might have been a member of the Mafia, given the Italian heritage of many victims, while others propose the murders were sexually motivated. The letter's claim that the Axeman was "a spirit and a demon from the hottest hell" fueled superstitious fears, though investigators focused on human suspects. Despite these efforts, no definitive evidence has emerged to identify the Axeman.

Investigation: A City in Fear

The New Orleans police launched extensive investigations, interviewing hundreds of witnesses and pursuing numerous leads. The city was gripped by terror, with residents taking extreme measures—staying awake all night, arming themselves, or playing jazz music continuously—to ward off the unseen threat. Yet, despite these efforts, the police were unable to apprehend the Axeman, and the attacks ceased as mysteriously as they began in October 1919.

Cultural Impact: The Axeman's Legacy

The Axeman's tale has left an indelible mark on popular culture, inspiring books, podcasts, and television shows. Notably, he was featured in the third season of "American Horror Story: Coven." The jazz connection also spawned creative works, such as the 1919 song "The Mysterious Axeman's Jazz (Don't Scare Me Papa)" by J.J. Davilla, reflecting the public's fascination with the case.

The Axeman's targeting of Italian immigrants underscored ethnic tensions in New Orleans at the time. The Italian community, already facing discrimination, lived in heightened fear, with many believing the attacks were racially motivated. Paradoxically, this period saw jazz music rise as a unifying force, as residents banded together to protect themselves through sound. Today, the Axeman remains a symbol of the unknown—a haunting reminder of a city held captive by an unseen predator.

In conclusion, the Axeman of New Orleans remains a figure shrouded in mystery and dread. His brutal attacks, the bizarre jazz letter, and the unresolved nature of his identity ensure that his story continues to captivate and unsettle. Like many historical enigmas, the truth may never surface, but the legend of the Axeman endures as a chilling chapter in New Orleans' history.

What are your thoughts on the Axeman of New Orleans? Do you have any theories about his identity? Share your opinions below.